Connect with us

Global News

Why Facebook Shutting Down Its Old Facial Recognition System Doesn’t Matter

Published

on

On Monday morning, Meta — the company formerly known as Facebook — announced that it would be shutting down “the Face Recognition system on Facebook,” a technology that has been raising privacy alarms since it debuted. In a blog post, the company described the move as “one of the biggest shifts in facial recognition usage in the technology’s history.” On Twitter, outgoing CTO Mike Schroepfer and incoming CTO Andrew Bosworth, who previously oversaw Facebook’s Oculus virtual reality division, called the announcement a “big deal” and a “very important decision.” The Electronic Frontier Foundation deemed it “a testament to all the hard work activists have done to push back against this invasive technology.”

But a review of Meta and Facebook’s VR privacy policies, and the company’s answers to a detailed list of questions about them, suggest the company’s face identification technology isn’t going anywhere. And it is only one of many invasive data collection methods that may be coming to a metaverse near you. (Disclosure: In a previous life, I held policy positions at Facebook and Spotify.)

Facebook’s recent announcement that it is shutting off its controversial facial recognition system comes at a difficult time for the company, which is facing significant regulatory scrutiny after years of bad press recently inflamed by a high-profile whistleblower.

But the moment may also be an opportune one. The company is shifting its focus to virtual reality, a face-worn technology that, by necessity, collects an enormous amount of data about its users. From this data, Meta will have the capacity to create identification and surveillance systems that are at least as powerful as the system it’s putting out to pasture. Just because it can create those systems doesn’t mean it will. For the moment, though, the company is leaving its options open.

The fact is: Meta intends to collect unique, identifying information about its users’ faces. Last week, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg told Stratechery’s Ben Thompson that “one of the big new features” of Meta’s new Cambria headset “is around eye-tracking and face-tracking.” And while the platform has “turned off the service” that previously created facial profiles of Facebook users, the New York Times reported that the company is keeping the algorithm on which that service relied. A Meta spokesperson declined to answer questions from BuzzFeed News about how that algorithm remains in use today.

Meta may have shut down the facial recognition system on Facebook that raised so many concerns, but given that it intends to keep the algorithm that powered that system, there is no reason the company couldn’t “simply turn it on again later,” according to David Brody, senior counsel at the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law.

Meanwhile, Meta’s current privacy policies for VR devices leave plenty of room for the collection of personal, biological data that reaches beyond a user’s face. As Katitza Rodriguez, policy director for global privacy at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, noted, the language is “broad enough to encompass a wide range of potential data streams — which, even if not being collected today, could start being collected tomorrow without necessarily notifying users, securing additional consent, or amending the policy.”

By necessity, virtual reality hardware collects fundamentally different data about its users than social media platforms do. VR headsets can be taught to recognize a user’s voice, their veins, or the shading of their iris, or to capture metrics like heart rate, breath rate, and what causes their pupils to dilate. Facebook has filed patents concerning many of these data collection types, including one that would use things like your face, voice, or even your DNA to lock and unlock devices. Another would consider a user’s “weight, force, pressure, heart rate, pressure rate, or EEG data” to create a VR avatar. Patents are often aspirational — covering potential use cases that never arise — but they can sometimes offer insight into a company’s future plans.

Meta’s current VR privacy policies do not specify all the types of data it collects about its users. The Oculus Privacy Settings, Oculus Privacy Policy, and Supplemental Oculus Data Policy, which govern Meta’s current virtual reality offerings, provide some information about the broad categories of data that Oculus devices collect. But they all specify that their data fields (things like “the position of your headset, the speed of your controller and changes in your orientation like when you move your head”) are just examples within those categories, rather than a full enumeration of their contents.

The examples given also do not convey the breadth of the categories they’re meant to represent. For example, the Oculus Privacy Policy states that Meta collects “information about your environment, physical movements, and dimensions when you use an XR device.” It then provides two examples of such collection: information about your VR play area and “technical information like your estimated hand size and hand movement.”

But “information about your environment, physical movements, and dimensions” could describe data points far beyond estimated hand size and game boundary — it also could include involuntary reaction metrics, like a flinch, or uniquely identifying movements, like a smile.

Meta twice declined to detail the types of data that its devices collect today and the types of data that it plans to collect in the future. It also declined to say whether it is currently collecting, or plans to collect, biometric information such as heart rate, breath rate, pupil dilation, iris recognition, voice identification, vein recognition, facial movements, or facial recognition. Instead, it pointed to the policies linked above, adding that “Oculus VR headsets currently do not process biometric data as defined under applicable law.” A company spokesperson declined to specify which laws Meta considers applicable.

Meta did, however, offer additional information about how it uses personal data in advertising. The Supplemental Oculus Terms of Service say that Meta may use information about “actions [users] have taken in Oculus products” to serve them ads and sponsored content. Depending on how Oculus defines “action,” this language could allow it to target ads based on what makes us jump from fear, or makes our hearts flutter, or our hands sweaty.

But at least for the moment, Meta won’t be targeting ads that way. Instead, a spokesperson told BuzzFeed News that the company is using a narrower definition of “actions” — one that does not include the movement data collected by a user’s VR device.

In a 2020 document called “Responsible Innovation Principles,” Facebook Reality Labs describes its approach to the metaverse. The first of these principles, “Never Surprise People,” begins: “We are transparent about how our products work and the data they collect.” Responding to questions from BuzzFeed News, Meta said it will be upfront about any future changes, should they arise, to how it will collect and use our data.

Without better clarity about the data that Meta is collecting today, “customers cannot make an informed choice about when and how to use their products,” Brody told BuzzFeed News. More to the point, it’s hard for the public to understand any future changes Meta might make to how it collects and uses our data if it’s never explained exactly what it’s doing now.

Brittan Heller, counsel at the law firm Foley Hoag and an expert in human rights and virtual reality, put it differently: “The VR industry is kind of in a ‘magic eight ball’ phase right now. On questions about privacy and safety, the answer that flutters up says, ‘Outlook uncertain: ask again later.'”

Read More

Original Post: buzzfeednews.com

Global News

11/25/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Published

on

11/25/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Access National Security News HERE.

Access Korean News HERE.

National Security News Content:

1. For Afghan Refugees, a Choice Between Community and Opportunity
2. Army Whistle-Blower’s Lonely Death Highlights Toll of Mental Illness
3. Chinese Communist Party will outlive United States–state media editor
4. Over-the-Horizon Counterterrorism: New Name, Same Old Challenges
5. After 9/11, the United States Didn’t Fight a Twenty-Year War, but Twenty One-Year Wars. But What Does that Actually Mean?
6. The Taiwan Foreign Policy Fetish – OpEd
7. Philippines rejects China’s demand to remove ship from shoal
8. CIA director warns Russian spies of ‘consequences’ if they are behind ‘Havana Syndrome’ incidents
9. U.S. Lawmakers Coming to Taiwan on Military-Focused Trip -Report
10. U.S. Invitation to Taiwan for Democracy Summit Tests Ties With China
11. Who was snubbed, who snuck through: Here’s the list of invitees to Biden’s democracy summit
12. Biden administration blacklists 27 companies over national security concerns
13. All options fraught with risk as Biden confronts Putin over Ukraine
14. Are our Intellectual Actions Aligned with our Security Challenges?
15. Senior U.S. officials present tougher stance ahead of Iran nuclear talks
16. Why the Marine Corps wants to tank National Guard recruiting efforts
17. Is the United States ready to take on China?
18. Trump Reportedly Approved Pentagon’s ‘Irregular Warfare’ Campaign Against Iran Before Exiting WH
19. CIA Opens New Accessibility Storefront at Headquarters – CIA
20. Michael Flynn ups the conspiracy ante, says COVID released by “global elites”
21. A MACV-SOG Thanksgiving: When 6 commandos took on 30,000 enemy troops
22. Japan plans record boost to ‘sympathy budget’ for hosting US military bases: source

Korean News Content:

1. North Korea’s Push for Reunification Isn’t Just Empty Rhetoric
2. Meeting North Koreans outside the country in freedom
3. N. Korean border patrol’s food provisions heavily impacted by COVID-19 border closure
4. Why Has North Korea Struggled to Normalize Trade With China?
5. Will Japan-South Korea Relations Ever Get Back on Track?
6. S. Korea-U.S. talks on OPCON transfer proceed ‘very amicably’: official
7. North Korea bans leather coats to stop citizens from copping leader’s iconic look
8. FM Chung says comfort women ‘atrocity’ should not be forgotten
9. Seoul monitoring possibility of new N.K. event marking 2017 ICBM launch
10. Lee says appeasement more effective than sanctions in dealing with N. Korea
11. South Korea longs for Trump’s focus as efforts to engage Pyongyang stall
12. U.S. Shows up Korea’s Lack of Investment Strategy
13. South Korea presidential hopeful seeks closer ties with Pyongyang
14. North Korea’s Yongbyon Nuclear Complex: Further Evidence of 5 MWe Reactor Operations
15. The North Korea-Iran Relationship: An Anti-American Alliance or Transactional Partnership?

Dave Maxwell
Thu, 11/25/2021 – 11:50am

Read more about 11/25/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary
2 comments

Log in or register to post commentsRead More

Original Article: smallwarsjournal.com

Continue Reading

Global News

11/27/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Published

on

11/27/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Access National Security News HERE.

Access Korean News HERE.

National Security News Content:

1. Why wiping out Hong Kong’s opposition may have cost China a whole generation in Taiwan
2. Opinion | The U.S. must defend itself from the omicron variant — without resorting to lockdowns
3. Opinion | The newest coronavirus variant is raising alarms. The pandemic is not over.
4. Russia-Ukraine border: Why Moscow is stoking tensions
5. Four Psychological Mechanisms That Make Us Fall for Disinformation
6. America must prepare for war with China over Taiwan
7. Russia Has Bigger Plans Beyond Ukraine and Belarus
8. Australia Needs Asymmetric Capabilities to Counter China in Indo-Pacific, Former Australian Official Says
9. China Is Closing Another Major Bridge to Taiwan
10. Why medium-sized autocracies are projecting more hard power abroad
11. U.S. lawmakers say Taiwan “on the rise” as they ignore China warnings to visit country
12. Afghan Teachers Defy Taliban by Secretly Schooling Teenage Girls
13. Expand Five Eyes to Nine? That’s Four Too Many
14. US no longer names foreign troops on Taiwan as trigger for China conflict
15. How to Deter Russia Now

Korean News Content:

1. What to do about North Korea
2. Report casts doubt on claim a North Korean was sentenced to death for smuggling ‘Squid Game’
3. Exam skills won’t help you survive ‘Squid Game’
4. Late ex-President Chun’s wife apologizes for ‘pains, scars’ inflicted during his presidency
5. Daily cases bounce back above 4,000, deaths hit record high
6. South Korea’s KSTAR Fusion Reaction Breaks Own Record, Self-Sustaining Nuclear Energy Power Source?
7. 21 Sakhalin Koreans return to home country
8. Moon appoints two deputy chiefs of spy agency
9. 3 reasons Lee Jae-myung and the Democratic Party are losing ground

Dave Maxwell
Sat, 11/27/2021 – 8:32am

Read more about 11/27/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary
2 comments

Log in or register to post commentsRead More

Original Article: smallwarsjournal.com

Continue Reading

Global News

11/28/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Published

on

11/28/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Access National Security News HERE.

Access Korean News HERE.

National Security News Content:

1. US risks ‘Suez moment’ in a Taiwan war
2. What we know so far about Omicron
3. Why ‘Confrontation’ with China Cannot Be Avoided
4. Israel and Iran Broaden Cyberwar to Attack Civilian Targets
5. Taliban Covert Operatives Seized Kabul, Other Afghan Cities From Within
6. From my dad’s death in Afghanistan 20 years ago to Taliban retaking the country. How did we get here? by Jake Spann
7. America has forgotten the lesson of total war | Column
8. Opinion | The Military’s Broken Culture Around Sexual Violence and Suicide
9. Inside Wagnergate: Ukraine’s Brazen Sting Operation to Snare Russian Mercenaries
10. Geopolitical Challenges Cloud Next Chapter in Xi’s Triumphalist History
11. Can America Afford to Take Care of Its Veterans?
12. The Navy is testing a GPS-like device that doesn’t require satellites
13. The United Kingdom: Exclusive: Ranger Regiment selection process before taking on Special Forces roles
14. Opinion | Alex Jones is facing a reckoning. Let it be a warning to other conspiracy theorists.
15. As America retreats, regional rogues are on the rise
16. US misses golden opportunity in the Solomon Islands

Korean News Content:

1. President Moon makes last-ditch effort to realize North Korea talks within tenure
2. Seoul bids for Hong Kong’s crown as Asia’s financial hub
3. Apology by Chun’s widow not meant for Gwangju massacre victims
4. Can Korea and Japan survive issues of history?
5. Can Korea learn from ASEAN to navigate US-China tensions?
6. Coronavirus is surging in South Korea thanks to an eye-poking sect. That’s bad news for Kim Jong Un
7. Chinese police capture North Korean convict on the run
8. Could North Korea Pull the U.S. and China Into a Nuclear War?
9. Intimate Perspectives on North Korea by Fabian Muir – in pictures

Dave Maxwell
Sun, 11/28/2021 – 11:18am

Read more about 11/28/2021 National Security and Korean News and Commentary

Log in or register to post commentsRead More

Source Here: smallwarsjournal.com

Continue Reading

Trending

News9Media.com